Fateh Khan Baru had sent word to all muhajirin through Malik Bakhkhan^RZ, “The mullahs have said that they wanted to debate the question of Mahdiat with you.” All the muhajirin assembled at the village of Munib. Bandagi Miyan Syed Khundmir^RZ advised all the muhajirin, “All of you come to a consensus that only one man would reply to the opponents. All the muhajirin agreed to the suggestion. Bandagi Miyan^RZ told Bandagi Miyan Shah Nizam^RZ, “How would you reply to the debate?” Miyan Nizam^RZ said, “This servant will prove the zath of Imam Mahdi^AS by the traditions (hadis) of Prophet Muhammad^SLM.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ said, “This is not the reply because there is great contradiction in the traditions. The munkir (opponent) of Imam Mahdi^AS will not accept the arguments.” Then he turned to Bandagi Miyan Shah Nemat^RZ, “What would be your reply?” Shah Nemat^RZ said, “This servant will prove the zath of Imam Mahdi^AS by one Verse of Quran and one tradition of Prophet^SLM. It is good if the opponent accepts. Otherwise, I will show the sword and ask if he accepts it.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ said, “This is not the reply.” Then he asked Bandagi Miyan Shah Dilawar^RZ, “What would be your reply?” Miyan Dilawar^RZ said, “This servant will answer after ascertaining from Allah.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ said, “This too is not the (proper) answer. The opponent will not accept ascertaining from Allah.” Then he asked Miyan Malikji^RZ, “What would be your answer?” Miyan Malikji^RZ said, “This servant will prove the zath of Imam Mahdi^AS by the similitude of the zath of Prophet Muhammad^SLM.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ said, “The munkir of Imam Mahdi^AS will not accept similitude.” He then turned to Miyan Amin Muhammad^RZ, “What would be your reply?” Miyan Amin Muhammad^RZ said, “This servant will prove the zath of the Imam^AS through the glory of the Prophets^AS.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ said, “The munkir of the Imam^AS will not accept the glory of the Prophets^AS.” Miyan Khundmir^RZ asked some other muhajirin about their replies. They answered according to their ability. Miyan Khundmir^RZ could not accept their replies too. Then Miyan Malikji^RZ asked Miyan Khundmir^RZ, “What would be your answer?” Miyan Khundmir^RZ then said, “If all the muhajirin permit me, I will tell about my answer.” All the muhajirin gave the permission. Then Miyan Syed Khundmir^RZ said, “As the sadaqa of our khundkar Mahdi, I will prove the vilayat of Imam Mahdi^AS on the authority of the first letter, Alif, to the last word, wannas, of the Quran, “All the companions affirmed that the person who can give such proof is the honoured (ikram). All the companions paid fealty to Bandagi Miyan Syed Khundmir^RZ by saying, “You are the buzurg among us. Bandagi Miyan^RZ explained the Verse, Afa man kana…, and some other Verses of the Quran. However, the mullahs felt defeated even before the debate started and refrained from joining the debate. They were disgraced. This narration is from the village Nabib.